Menu
Go back

Perspectives

The Gulf and France

Ben Ashby

Scroll down

Part One: Nothing Is Over

I’ve just got back from a business trip to the Persian Gulf. To borrow from John Rambo at the end of the movie First Blood: “Nothing is over! Nothing! You just don’t turn it off.”

 

The working assumption is that hostilities pick up now that the November midterms are over. The Wall Street Journal reported that Washington had told Gulf allies to expect a short, sharp campaign against Iran once the votes are in. Nobody could tell me how it ends.

 

The damage is real, and repairs will be slow. Money isn’t the constraint; kit is. The big turbines that drive LNG plants come from three makers with multi-year order books, largely thanks to data centers. The AI boom and the Gulf rebuild are queuing for the same machines.

 

Qatar lost two trains at Ras Laffan in March, about 17% of export capacity, and repairs could take up to five years. In late October, QatarEnergy extended force majeure on LNG deliveries to the end of December. Crude is getting through Hormuz; LNG largely isn’t. European gas is at its highest since 2022, and winter hasn’t started.

 

But the conversation kept coming back to Saudi Arabia. The war with the Houthis is going badly: missiles on Saudi airports, more than 20 dead in October, Aramco’s offices hit. Riyadh now expects its economy to shrink 3.6% this year. And there is growing unease about how the kingdom is being run, and by whom.

 

That deserves a longer piece, and I’ll come back to it, as Saudi Arabia has a number of structural challenges that events in the region may well accelerate. For now, markets are pricing Iran. I’m not sure they’re pricing Riyadh.

Part Two: We’ll Always Have Paris

Earlier this year, in “Europe: A User’s Guide,” I argued that European equities were cheap for a reason: a system slowly running out of organizational energy. In the grand sweep of European history, basically a Tuesday.

If Europe is the manual, France is the chapter with the warnings. It now pays more to borrow for 10 years than Italy. Not a sentence many of us expected to write, but as a Brit I find myself unencumbered by tears in my eyes and able to write this with surprising fortitude.

“Who Am I?”

France hasn’t balanced a budget since 1974. Like one of writer Saki’s Edwardian dandies, it lives so far beyond its income that the two may almost be said to be living apart. Every government promises restraint. Every government discovers this isn’t the year.

 

Debt hit a record 119% of GDP in June, up from about 65% in 2007. The deficit will be around 5.4% this year, the fourth year in a row above 5%. The state spends 57% of GDP, the most in the euro area, and already taxes about 44%. So, the problem isn’t revenue. It’s spending, chiefly pensions. The 2023 reform raising the retirement age was duly suspended to keep the government alive.

 

The 2027 budget aims for a 5% deficit, and even then, debt keeps rising. The Socialists call it a “bitter austerity potion.” In Paris, borrowing 5% of GDP now counts as austerity.

 

France has had four prime ministers since January 2024. Each was a good prime minister, as prime ministers go. And, as prime ministers go, they went. M. Lecornu went too, then came back four days later. He is still with us… for now. The Assembly threw out the social security budget on October 23, and on November 3, the same day the US voted, it rejected the state budget in its entirety (quelle surprise).

“Do You Hear the People Sing?”

As amusing as it is to watch Paris’ Temu rendition of Les Misérables, on the headline numbers, Washington is the bigger spender. The federal deficit for the year just ended was almost $2 trillion, about 6% of GDP, and the IMF puts general government debt near 125%. As a Brit who watched gilts melt down in 2022, I’d suggest nobody assumes bond markets only punish other people.

 

That said, the private sector is a key difference. Since the 2008 crisis, American households have cut their debt from 98% of GDP to 68%, and total US private debt has fallen from 172% to 140%, its lowest since 2001. France went the other way—159% in 2007, a peak of 240% in 2020, and still 215% at the end of 2025, most of it corporate.

 

Put crudely: in America, the government borrowed so households could repair their balance sheets. In France, everybody borrowed.

In fairness, French ratios have eased since 2021. French households still owe less than American ones, but French corporates do not. And though some of that corporate debt is intra-group, none of that changes 17 years of direction. It matters because when a state tightens, someone else has to spend. A deleveraged American private sector can. A heavily indebted French one can’t.

“I Dreamed a Dream”

And America prints its own currency. France doesn’t. It can’t devalue, can’t inflate its way out alone, and can’t lean on its central bank, while 57% of its bonds sit with foreigners who have no vote and plenty of alternatives.

 

Will the ECB ride to the rescue? Unlike the beginning of the last Eurodebacle, it now has both a playbook and a tool for this: the Transmission Protection Instrument. The ECB has always been ready to help those who help themselves. France has always assumed it would help regardless. But the bar is high. The TPI is meant for spreads not justified by fundamentals, and France’s spread is all fundamentals and not just economic ones; it is growing politically unstable too. It requires compliance with EU fiscal rules. The ECB is raising rates, not cutting, with inflation at 3.8%. And on October 29 Christine Lagarde said she will leave in February, nine months early, a move widely linked to April’s French election. The lifeguard is changing shifts just as the swimmer struggles.

 

The ECB’s older tool, the OMT, needs a conditional bailout program. Can you picture a French government signing before a presidential election? Or even after a presidential election? Neither can I.

 

Meanwhile, Marine Le Pen, whom the FT labels as the ‘Far Right,’ held her first big campaign rally on October 25, leading every poll. The EU has always believed in democracy, provided it is exercised responsibly and in the right direction it approves of. Elect a government that tears up the fiscal rules and the safety net goes with them. France has the distinction of being too large to scold and too proud to be helped, which in a person would be called character and in a sovereign borrower is called a spread.

Gradually, Then Suddenly

In Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, a bankrupt Scot is asked how it happened. “Two ways,” he says. “Gradually and then suddenly.”

 

France is still in the gradual phase; long-dated debt means higher yields bite slowly and actual default at this stage seems remote. But the calendar for “suddenly” is filling up: S&P rating review on November 27, a change at the top of the ECB in February, the election in April. Hard to see this getting better before it gets worse.

 

For American investors, two things. First, French bonds are no longer a near-Bund; price them as a large, liquid, politically risky credit. And check what your “diversified” international bond fund owns. France is rarely a small position. Second, France’s distress will likely spread both into other countries and into the financial system.

 

In the movie Casablanca, Rick told Ilsa, “We’ll always have Paris.” He didn’t mention the bonds.

 

* To my many French friends and former colleagues: désolé. Again. We will no doubt be joining you soon enough.

References

Ashby, Ben. 2026. “Europe: A User’s Guide.” Sowell Week Ahead, March 2.

 

Hemingway, Ernest. 1926. The Sun Also Rises. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.

 

Landini, Francesca, and Gianluca Semeraro. 2026. “Edison, South Asian Gas Buyers Face QatarEnergy Supply Halt Until Year-End.” Reuters, October 28.

 

Ratney, Michael. 2026. “Saudi Arabia Faces the Era of Disequilibrium.” Center for Strategic & International Studies, September 24.

 

Said, Summer, Shelby Holliday, Benoit Faucon, and Anat Peled. 2026. “U.S. Warns Gulf of Possible Short, Intense Renewal of Iran War After Midterms.” Wall Street Journal, October 28.

 

Warner Bros. Entertainment. “Casablanca 70th Anniversary Edition | We’ll Always Have Paris.” YouTube video.

 

Wikipedia. “European Central Bank.” Last updated October 30, 2026.

 

Wikipedia. “Eurozone Crisis.” Last updated October 9, 2026.

 

Wikipedia. “First Blood.” Last updated November 1, 2026.

 

Wikipedia. “Les Misérables.” Last updated October 31, 2026.

 

 

Disclosures: Ben Ashby is Head of Fixed Income & Foreign Exchange at Rayliant Investment Research (“RIR”), an SEC-registered investment adviser; registration does not imply any level of skill or training. He is employed by Henderson Rowe Limited, an affiliate of RIR, and is a member of Sowell Management’s OCIO team. This material is informational only; it is not investment, tax or legal advice, or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security, and does not consider any investor’s individual objectives, financial situation or needs. Investors should consult their financial professional before making investment decisions. Views are the author’s as of the publication date and may change. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Third-party data is believed reliable but not guaranteed.